THE LOW ENERGY CHARGED PARTICLE (LECP) EXPERIMENT ON THE VOYAGER
SPACECRAFT
Copyright © 1977 Kluwer Academic
Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, London.
Reprinted with permission of Kluwer Academic Publishers.
This material is posted here with permission of Kluwer Academic Publishers (Kluwer). Such permission of Kluwer does not in any way imply Kluwer endorsement of any PDS product or service. Internal or personal use of this material is permitted. However, permission to reprint/republish this material for advertising or promotional purposes or for creating new collective works for resale or redistribution must be obtained from Kluwer.
By choosing to view this document, you agree to all provisions of the copyright laws protecting it.
THE LOW ENERGY CHARGED PARTICLE (LECP) EXPERIMENT ON THE VOYAGER SPACECRAFT
S. M. KRIMIGIS
The Johns Hopkins University, Applied Physics Laboratory, Laurel, Md 20810, U.S.A.
T. P. ARMSTRONG
Department of Physics, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66044, U.S.A.
W. I. AXFORD
Max-Planck Institute for Aeronomy, D- 3411 Katlenburg- Lindau 3, West Germany
C. O. BOSTROM
The Johns Hopkins University, Applied Physics Laboratory, Laurel, Md 20810, U.S.A.
C. Y. FAN
Department of Physics, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona 85721, U.S.A.
G. GLOECKLER
Department of Physics & Astronomy, University of Maryland, College Park, Md 20742, U.S.A.
and
L. J. LANZEROTTI
Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, New Jersey 07904, U.S.A.
(Received 24 May, 1977)
Abstract. The Low Energy Charged Particle (LECP) experiment on the Voyager spacecraft is designed to provide comprehensive measurements of energetic particles in the Jovian, Saturnian, Uranian and interplanetary environments. These measurements will be used in establishing the morphology of the magnetospheres of Saturn and Uranus, including bow shock, magnetosheath, magnetotail, trapped radiation, and satellite-energetic particle interactions. The experiment consists of two subsystems, the Low Energy Magnetospheric Particle Analyzer (LEMPA) whose design is optimized for magnetospheric measurements, and the Low Energy Particle Telescope (LEPT) whose design is optimized for measurements in the distant magnetosphere and the interplanetary medium. The LEMPA covers the energy range from ~10 keV to > 11 MeV for electrons and from ~15 keV to 150 MeV for protons and heavier ions. The dynamic range is ~0.1 to 1011 cm-2 sec-1 sr-1 overall, and extends to 1013 cm-2 sec- 1 sr-1 in a current mode operation for some of the sensors. The LEPT covers the range ~0.05 E 40 MeV/nucleon with good energy and species resolution, including separation of isotopes over a smaller energy range. Multi- dE/dx measurements extend the energy and species coverage to 300-500 MeV/nucleon but with reduced energy and species resolution. The LEPT employs a set of solid state detectors ranging in thickness from 2 to ~2450 µ, and an arrangement of eight rectangular solid state detectors in an anticoincidence cup. Both subsystems are mounted on a stepping platform which rotates through eight angular sectors with rates ranging from 1 revolution per 48 min to 1 revolution per 48 sec. A 'dome' arrangement mounted on LEMPA allows acquisition of angular distribution data in the third dimension at low energies. The data system contains sixty-two 24-bit scalers accepting data from 88 separate channels with near 100% duty cycle, a redundant 256-channel pulse height analyzer (PHA), a priority system for selecting unique LEPT events for PHA analysis, a command and control system, and a fully redundant interface with the spacecraft. Other unique features of the LECP include logarithmic amplifiers particle identifiers, fast (~15 ns FWHM) pulse circuitry for some subsystems, inflight electronic and source calibration and several possible data modes.
1. Introduction
According to the best available estimates the solar wind extends as a supersonic flow to a heliocentric distance of the order of 50 AU or more, i.e., beyond the orbits of Neptune and Pluto (Axford, 1972). Thus the solar wind must interact with the magnetospheres of all the planets or with their atmospheres or surfaces in cases where the planets have no internal magnetic field. Furthermore, the solar wind must interact with the satellites of any planets which are not shielded by planetary magnetospheres.
The study of the physics of planetary magnetospheres is of considerable scientific interest in itself (Kennel, 1973). It is also of great importance in furthering our understanding of certain astronomical objects (notably pulsars and compact X-ray sources), the origin of satellites of the outer planets, and perhaps the origin of the Solar System itself (e.g., Cameron, 1973; Alfvén and Arrhenius, 1976). The existence of planetary magnetospheres presents opportunities for making direct in-situ observations of particle acceleration mechanisms, thereby leading to the possibility of achieving a better understanding of solar flare processes, cosmic ray acceleration processes, and processes in the Earth's magnetosphere. In the case of the Jovian satellite Io (and possibly other planetary satellites) there is an apparent strong interaction with the magnetosphere of the parent planet which induces intense radio emissions by mechanisms which although not well understood at present, could be of importance for understanding other astrophysical radio sources. In addition there is some evidence that planetary magnetospheres can play an important role in determining the surface structure of satellites (Mendis and Axford, 1974).
To date spacecraft launched from Earth have probed the environment around five of the nine planets in the Solar System. Spacecraft instrumentation has also investigated various aspects of the satellites of Earth, Mars and Jupiter. The nature of the Earth's magnetosphere has been investigated in considerable detail and a rather good morphological understanding of the phenomena that can occur has been obtained. Yet, understanding in depth of many detailed plasma processes remains elusive (Williams, 1975). The interaction of the solar wind with the Earth's moon has been investigated extensively; this interaction is a clear case of the impinging of the solar wind plasma on an essentially non-conducting and non-magnetized body that does not have an atmosphere. The bow shock and magnetic tail of the Mercurian magnetosphere have been detected and it has been observed that electron acceleration seems to occur even in this relatively simple case where there are no complications induced by the presence of a planetary atmosphere or ionosphere (Ness et al., 1975). The magnetosphere situations around both Mars and Venus are somewhat unclear at the present time: there appear to be bow shocks and plasma tails associated with each planet and there is also some evidence for a Martian magnetic field of internal origin (Dolginov et al., 1972).
Of the giant planets, the Jovian magnetosphere has been examined during flybys of Pioneer 10 and 11. It is now well documented that for this planet (a) there are pronounced magnetic field effects associated with the rotation of the planet (Smith et al., 1974); (b) relativistic electrons are present with unexpectedly high fluxes (Fillius and McIlwain, 1974); (c) the Galilean satellites play a significant role in absorbing and perhaps accelerating particles (Fillius and McIlwain, 1974); and (d) energetic particles are injected by the planet into the interplanetary medium (Chenette et al., 1974) where they can be detected even at the orbit of the Earth (Krimigis et al., 1975b). No spacecraft has visited Saturn as yet, but radio emissions from this planet have now been observed (Brown, 1975) so that a Saturnian magnetosphere undoubtedly exists. A unique characteristic of that magnetosphere will be the interaction of energetic particles with Saturn's rings and composition changes or 'sputtering' therefrom.
The planet Uranus will undoubtedly present an essentially new kind of magnetosphere that may well demonstrate some remarkable features. The spin axis of the planet lies essentially in the ecliptic plane and at the time of the expected Voyager encounter in 1986 the axis of rotation of the planet will be pointing at the Sun to within a few degrees (Alexander, 1965). If the axis of rotation and the axis of the dipole component of the magnetic field are roughly coincident (as for the Earth and Jupiter), then the spacecraft will encounter, pole-onward, a rapidly rotating magnetosphere which is lying on its side (e.g., Siscoe, 1975).
The flyby encounters with Jupiter, Saturn and possibly Uranus, although of paramount importance in the design considerations for the LECP, will account for only a few percent of the total time duration of the Voyager mission. Prior to the Jovian encounter, between the Jovian and the Saturnian encounters, and after the Saturnian encounter there exists the opportunity to explore in depth the interplanetary medium at great distances from the Sun. Furthermore, since the two Voyager spacecraft will be in the same region of the Solar System, there will be a unique opportunity for making important correlated measurements among two spacecraft with identical instrumentation in the most distant parts of the heliosphere. Finally, the Voyager spacecraft will be travelling away from the Sun in the general direction of the postulated solar apex.
From the point of view of charged particle observations the Voyager mission and the LECP will make it possible to measure the energy spectra and composition of galactic cosmic rays in a region of space where the effects of solar modulation can be expected to be substantially less than those ever probed previously. The most important interplanetary energetic particle measurements made by LECP will be those investigating: (1) the spectra of the various atomic species comprising the galactic cosmic radiation, especially at low energies; (2) time variations of galactic cosmic rays (including Forbush decreases); (3) the radial gradient of galactic cosmic rays; (4) energetic particles of solar origin associated with flares and active regions; (5) energetic particles of planetary origin such as those observed to be associated with Jupiter as well as the Earth (Krimigis et al., 1975a); and (6) energetic particles associated with interplanetary forward-reverse shock pairs (Smith and Wolfe, 1976). In addition to providing detailed energy spectra, the detector system will make highly accurate measurements of the anisotropies of low energy cosmic rays and other energetic particles, since such anisotropies can provide a means of identifying the origins of the particles as well as shedding further light on the physics of interplanetary propagation processes.
The LECP contains detector configurations specifically designed to cover the energy range 15 keVE 40 MeV/nucleon with good energy, angular, and temporal resolution; coverage is also obtained to higher nucleon energies (~300-500 MeV/nucleon), but with lesser energy and species resolution overall.
This system will ideally complement an experiment designed to observe low energy (10 keV) solar wind and magnetospheric plasmas, a magnetometer experiment, appropriate wave experiments, and a cosmic ray instrument at much higher energies. Fortunately, all of these experiments are included in the comprehensive Voyager payload.
2. Scientific Objectives and Background
The Voyager mission represents a unique opportunity to perform exploratory measurements at Saturn and probably Uranus, in the outer extremes of the interplanetary medium and (possibly) in the interstellar medium, and to conduct 'second generation' studies of the Jovian environment. The LECP instrument is designed to address the following objectives:
(1) Investigate the existence, spatial extent and dynamical morphology of Saturnian and Uranian magnetospheres and measure the spectral and angular distributions, composition and plasma flows of particles in the radiation belts, bow shock, transition region and magnetotail; determine the planetary and satellite magnetic moments and the nature of nonthermal radio emission.
(2)Investigate the quasi-steady energetic particle flux in interplanetary space for studying solar modulation mechanisms, the radial gradient and radial scale of modulation, short term modulation effects, the solar, galactic, and planetary components, and particle acceleration mechanisms in the interplanetary medium, and (possibly) the terminus of the heliosphere.
(3) Perform 'second generation' studies of the composition, energy spectrum, azimuthal and pitch angle distribution of Jovian magnetospheric charged particles bearing on questions of origin, transport, loss, and of sources of decameter and decimeter radio emission, including important satellite sweeping and source effects.
(4) Study the energetic particle environments of natural planetary satellites and deduce satellite magnetic moments, conductivities, and the electrodynamics of the interaction with the planetary magnetospheres (e.g., particle 'shadowing' studies and searches for field aligned particle currents).
(5) Make inferences concerning the origin and interstellar propagation of galactic cosmic rays, their confinement times and path length distributions, by measuring the elemental and isotopic composition and anisotropy of galactic particles after the Saturnian (Uranian) encounter.
(6) Study the propagation in the distant interplanetary medium of particles emitted at the Sun by investigating their intensity-time profiles, energy spectra, gradients, and anisotropies and the charge and isotope composition.
(7) Investigate large and small scale magnetic structures in the interplanetary medium and near planets using charged particle angular distributions in order to augment magnetometer measurements.
Because of space limitations, it is not possible to give an adequate discussion of the science background for all the objectives enumerated above. Thus we will limit our remarks to a few specific points which are illustrative of the measurement and interpretive possibilities utilizing the LECP data.
A. PLANETARY MAGNETOSPHERES
The first and most important objective here is the establishment of the morphology of the magnetospheres of Saturn and Uranus. Aside from this general objective, however, our experiment is especially designed to address specific problems within the magnetospheres of both planets, and of Jupiter as well. First we expect to obtain the three- dimensional distribution function of low energy electrons and ions, which is an essential tool in the study of wave-particle interactions and the underlying physical processes which give rise to plasma instabilities in planetary magnetospheres (e.g., Williams and Lyons, 1974). In addition we will obtain the compositional signature of energetic ions and thus be able to infer their sources, i.e., whether these ions originate in the solar wind, planetary ionosphere, or are 'sputtered' off planetary satellites, as appears to be the case at the orbit of Io (Brown, 1973). Further, the experiment is designed to make detailed angular distribution measurements while the spacecraft is traversing the Io flux tube at a distance of ~10 satellite radii. During this passage, the importance of Io as both a source and sink of energetic particles will be determined in a rather comprehensive manner. The implications of this measurement on the Io- associated decametric radio emissions is evident.
In addition to the above measurements, the low energy (~15 keV) proton threshold on the LEMPA allows direct measurement of moving hot plasmas of sufficiently high density. We have reported plasma flow and temperature measurements in the Earth's magnetotail, magnetosheath and upstream bow shock region (Roelof et al., 1976) using a detector with somewhat higher energy threshold (50 keV) and a geometric factor of only ~1/4 that of the LEMPA. Our technique deduces both the plasma bulk velocity and temperature from the anisotropy of the sectored fluxes. The sensitivity of the LEMPA to a moving Maxwellian plasma is illustrated in Figure 1. The peak integral flux from the direction of the plasma flow divided by the density (J0/N) is given as a function of 'thermal energy' Eth = kT in Figure 1a for 15 keV protons for three bulk flow velocities (and for 10 keV electrons, which are insensitive to plasma flow). The sample angular distribution (given in Figure 1b) for a 1 keV plasma flowing at a relatively low velocity of 100 km s- 1 exhibits an anisotropy sufficiently strong to determine the proton temperature. At a moderate 300 km s-1 (typical of the terrestrial magnetosheath), a plasma of density 10-2 cm- 3 would yield ~102 counts in the peak sector of the 15 keV proton LEMPA channel (while rotating at 1 RPM), allowing ~10% statistics for an anisotropy 'snapshot' every minute. In addition, Figure 1a demonstrates the high sensitivity of the 10 keV electron LEMPA channel to hot plasma (independent of bulk velocity), with rates ~102 s-1 even for densities as low as 10-6 cm- 3. Thus the lowest energy LEMPA channels are capable of measuring the high energy tail of plasmas with kT1 keV, while the higher energy channels span the physically important transition region to the nonthermal energy region (~300 keV) that often accompanies hot plasma flow as is the case in the outer terrestrial magnetosphere (Sarris et al., 1976). Measurements of such plasma flows have proved to be essential in delineating the dynamics of the Earth's magnetotail, including the substorm process and the 'plasma mantle' (Rosenbauer et al., 1975).
B. ENERGETIC PARTICLE MEASUREMENTS IN THE INTERPLANETARY MEDIUM
The recent reports of observations of solar particle events with long- lasting anisotropies, together with the measurements of very small cosmic ray radial gradients by Pioneer 10 and 11 instruments have raised several interesting and important questions about the underlying theoretical considerations of both the modulation and energy loss of galactic cosmic rays in the Solar System as well as of the size of the solar modulation region. In addition, the important recent discoveries of planetary particle contributions to the interplanetary particle fluxes (Teegarden et al., 1974; Chenette et al., 1974; Krimigis et al., 1975a) and the anomalous abundance of low energy C and O nuclei (Klecker et al., 1975) reveal a situation considerably more complex than the hypothesis that all low energy cosmic rays observed near 1 AU result from the energy losses of low energy galactic particles entering the solar modulation region (Fisk et al., 1974).
The degree of our understanding of cosmic-ray propagation in the heliosphere can be measured by the consistency of our explanation of particles streaming (a) from the Sun (b) from planetary magnetospheres and (c) from the galaxy. The persistent anisotropies of solar flare particles of energies 1-103 MeV (Roelof and Krimigis, 1973; Innanen and Van Allen, 1973; Duggal and Pomerantz, 1973; Wibberenz et al., 1976), the very small values of the radial cosmic-ray gradients out to 5 AU (Thomsen and Van Allen, 1976) and the appearance of Jovian magnetospheric particles near Earth (Krimigis et al., 1975b) all seem to indicate that the region of the Solar System within ~5 AU is characterized by relatively weak scattering of cosmic rays. If so, then the control of the 11-year solar modulation of cosmic ray intensity must lie in the region beyond 5 AU (unless the modulation and scattering mechanism is not at all adequately understood). Because of the possibly large extent of the modulation region (Axford, 1972) and because the cosmic ray radial gradient at any given energy is unlikely to be uniform as a function of heliocentric distance, our instruments on the two Voyager spacecraft will allow gradient measurements at points separated by relatively short distances (i.e., a few AU), as well as between instruments at large heliocentric distances and at the orbit of Earth.
C. SOLAR AND PLANETARY PARTICLES AS PROBES OF THE INTERPLANETARY MEDIUM
Solar energetic particle events provide valuable diagnostics of the large and small scale interplanetary plasma and magnetic field at large heliocentric distances. The sensitivity of a traditional tool used for solar event analyses, i.e., study of the velocity dispersion of event onsets, increases approximately as the square of the heliocentric radius for field-aligned propagation. Hence the persistence at large heliocentric distances of an anti-sunward field- aligned anisotropy as well as the development of a 'back-scattered' flux in the sunward direction will provide important diagnostics (even more sensitive than at 1 AU) on small scale magnetic irregularity structures inside and outside (respectively) the orbit of the spacecraft. The ability of the LECP to cleanly separate atomic species and isotopes during solar events will allow an analysis of Z/A propagation effects in the outer solar system.
In addition, both the Earth and Jupiter are sources (albeit of widely differing strengths) of low energy interplanetary particles with spectral, temporal and abundance signatures distinguishable from solar events. Consequently, planetary magnetospheres can also provide particles as 'tracers' of the large scale interplanetary field, at large distances, both upstream and down stream of the planet. LECP will provide the necessary energy, abundance, and anisotropy data to make strong use of these tracers.
Finally, interplanetary acceleration of energetic particles has been observed to occur both at 1 AU and in the outer Solar System. Three main mechanisms have been discussed in the literature with regard to particle acceleration (or deceleration) in the interplanetary medium; shock-associated acceleration (essentially in the shock electric field); adiabatic deceleration (essentially a gas- dynamic cooling due to expansion); and in-situ acceleration (supposedly a second-order Fermi process).
A critical evaluation of the two basic classes of particle shock- acceleration models (microscopic plasma dynamics and post-shock magnetic field) will be possible using our LECP anisotropy and spectral measurements of electrons and ions since the post-shock regions in the outer solar system will often differ substantially from those at 1 AU. The composition dependence of the shock effects (e.g., Armstrong and Krimigis, 1973) is of great interest under the shock conditions at large heliocentric distances.
Adiabatic deceleration occurs when particles are effectively 'convected' by the solar wind due to efficient scattering. Our LECP anisotropy and energy spectrum data will permit us to evaluate the possible importance of this process in the outer solar system.
3. Description of Instrumentation
Measurements fulfilling the requirements of the comprehensive investigation objectives described in the previous sections cannot be conducted with a single charged particle sensor. To attain the lowest energy of response over a wide variety of particle species and with appropriate geometry factors and angular resolution, the LECP utilizes two distinct all solid-state detector configurations each of which is optimized for a particular energy-intensity range and/or group of particle species. This procedure has the additional important advantage of providing overall experimental redundancy. The two detector subsystems designated as (a) The Low Energy Magnetospheric Particle Analyzer (LEMPA) and (b) The Low Energy Particle Telescope (LEPT) are described in the next two subsections. A picture of the flight instrument is shown in Figure 2. Both of these detector subsystems use multi-parameter detection techniques to provide measurements in over-lapping energy and intensity ranges; this redundancy increases system reliability and reduces background. Although the individual subsystems are optimized for either the interplanetary or magnetospheric environments, both subsystems will contribute substantial measurements which are important to both environments (Figure 8). The sun-shield used for both subsystems provides an additional unique and important function in that we are able to unambiguously determine the background counting rates for all system detectors and channels in both environments. Also, small radioactive sources for inflight calibration are mounted on the sunshield. Since the detector design was done prior to the Pioneer 10 encounter of Jupiter, certain changes were necessitated following the publication of the Pioneer results. The most important of these changes was the addition of substantial shielding to appropriate detector subsystems.
A. LOW ENERGY MAGNETOSPHERIC PARTICLE ANALYZER (LEMPA) SUBSYSTEM
The detectors in the LEMPA subsystem are designed for low energy thresholds (10-15 keV), clean separation of ions from electrons, good sensitivity, and large (~1011) dynamic range.
A schematic diagram of the detector arrangement in the LEMPA subsystem is shown in Figure 3. The functions of each detector are as follows:
Detector (protons, ions)
This is the primary detector for measuring protons-ions at low
energies (15 keV) with high sensitivity (G
~0.12 cm2 sr) and good energy resolution. It consists of a
25 mm2, 100 micron surface barrier totally-depleted
detector, with the aluminum side facing the incoming particle flux (to
minimize radiation damage). A rare-earth alloy magnet is used to
deflect electrons with energies 400 keV away from the
detector. These electrons are subsequently counted by detectors
and as described in the next
paragraph. The output from the detector is fed into
window-type discriminators which provide information in 10 proton-ion
differential channels at all times. The energy channels cover the
range ~0.015 to 4 MeV for protons and ions and 4 to 16 MeV for alphas.
The actual energy passbands, based on calibrations of the first flight
unit, are shown in Figure 4a. A gain switch
has been included in the P1 channel so that the
lowest threshold can be increased to ~25 keV, should the system noise
increase for any reason. The background counting rate of this detector
due to the presence of the spacecraft RTG is expected to range from 3
x 10-2 to 4.5 x 10-3 c/sec, i.e., at least an
order of magnitude below the omnidirectional cosmic ray background.
Note that tungsten shielding equivalent to the range of ~15 MeV
electrons minimizes background for most of the anticipated flyby
trajectory at Jupiter.
Detector and
(electrons)
These detectors are the primary ones for the measurement of low energy
(15 keV) electrons over a wide dynamic range with
good sensitivity (G ~ 0.002). Detector
is 5 mm2, 100 µ thick, while
detector is 5 mm2, 1000
µ thick; they are designed to measure the low and
intermediate energy portions of the electron spectrum, respectively.
The incoming beam of electrons is bent by the magnet onto the
detectors for pulse height analysis and intensity measurements. The
geometric factors and fields of view of detectors
and have been evaluated both by
trajectory-tracing of electrons of various energies in actual magnetic
field geometries and by initial calibration of the Voyager prototype
experiment. The angular response for monoenergetic beams of electrons
for the first flight unit is shown in Figure
4b, and it is evident that 10 keV electrons are readily counted by
detector . The differential channels at
maximum response are shown in Figure 4c. Both
detectors are designed to measure large fluxes in the Jovian
magnetosphere and at the same time be capable of measuring
interplanetary electrons such as those emitted in solar particle
events. The energy spectra available from detector
during planetary encounter will be crucial in examining, in
depth, particle acceleration and loss processes associated with
satellite interactions in the planetary magnetospheres. Both of these
detectors are also shielded from electrons with E
15 MeV. This shielding, however, may not be sufficient to
prevent background contamination at closest approach (L ~
5RJ) if the electron energy spectrum is indeed flat below
~160 keV (Fillius and McIlwain, 1974).
Detector ' (electrons)
This detector is used to measure electrons over the same energy
intervals as detector (10 to 200 keV) but with a field
of view centered 90° from that of
and perpendicular to the ecliptic plane
(Figure 3). Its main function is to provide detailed angular
distribution measurements not only in planetary magnetospheres, but
also in the interplanetary medium. Essentially complete electron pitch
angle distributions are obtained during magnetospheric encounters by
the use of the umbrella-like passive shield with narrow rectangular
look angles. The dome is mounted on a shaft coincident with the axis
perpendicular to the ecliptic plane about which the stepping motor
(see below) rotates the LEMPA and LEPT subsystems. Detector
' is a 5 mm2, 100 µ thick solid state
sensor located in a scatter geometry from the field of view (Figure 3). Electrons are single-scattered by
more than 90° from a gold foil and are incident on the detector
where they are pulse-height analyzed in 5 energy channels. The
electrons scatter efficiently (~1-10%) over most of this energy range
resulting in an efficiency-geometric factor of ~0.002 cm2
sr-1. Protons arriving through the open aperture cannot
reach the detector, although high energy (>70 MeV) protons can
penetrate the aluminum dome and the detector shield and contribute to
the counting rate. The shielding thickness has been determined after
review of the Pioneer 10 and 11 results. The RTG background is
identical to that for detector and does not
interfere with the proposed measurement objectives.
Detector (High Intensity Protons,
's and Z3 Nuclei)
The purpose of detector is to obtain
high intensity proton, alpha particle and Z
3 nuclei composition, energy spectra, and three-
dimensional angular distributions in the Saturnian, Uranian and Jovian
radiation belts. The design is optimized for a radius of closest
approach of ~5RJ and for the proton environment measured by
Pioneers 10 and 11. The sensor consists of a ~20 µ, 1
mm2 totally- depleted surface barrier solid state detector
of the type repeatedly flown in the Earth's radiation belt over the
past several years. The output from this detector is fed into a fast
(~15 ns FWHM) charge-sensitive pre-amplifier followed by several
threshold discriminators which provide proton, alpha particle, and
Z 3 measurements over the range 0.25
E2 MeV/nucleon. The maximum
apparent counting rate of this detector is ~4 x 106 c/sec
while the true counting rate corresponds to ~108 c/sec.
With a geometric factor of ~10- 3 cm2 sr-
1, the maximum measurable flux is ~ 1011 cm-
2 sec-1 sr-1, i.e., well above the
anticipated Jovian environment at L5RJ.
Detector ' (Protons, ions)
This detector is used to measure protons and ions at the same energy
intervals as detector but with a field
of view ranging up to 90° away from that of
by sharing the umbrella passive shield with detector
' (Figure 3). Together,
detectors and
' provide essentially complete three-dimensional proton
and ion pitch angle distributions during magnetospheric encounters.
Detector ' is a 1 mm2, 20
µ thick solid state detector and utilizes the same
electronics as detector .
Detectors AB (High Intensity - High Energy)
Detectors AB are included in the LEMPA package to increase the dynamic
range of the system in both energy and intensity to values well above
those measured by detectors ,
, and . Both devices are 5
mm2, ~300 µ thick surface barrier detectors
spaced ~5 mm apart inside shielding material. In the forward direction
detector B is shielded by 2.6 g cm-2 brass and detector A
by 0.35 g cm-2 magnesium. The detectors are operated in
both a coincidence and a singles count-rate mode. The outputs from
each detector are fed into fast (~50 ns FWHM pulse) charge-sensitive
preamplifiers followed by the appropriate discriminator and logic
circuitry. This circuitry, together with the shielding configurations,
define two semidirectional (i.e. , responding mostly over the forward
54°) electron channels in the range ~1.3-20 MeV, one coincidence
directional electron channel > 11 MeV, and two semidirectional
proton channels in the range 15-150 MeV. In addition, single detector
counting rates are monitored corresponding to differential proton
channels and single electron channels with maximum apparent rates of
~20 x 106 c sec-1 corresponding to true rates of
~109 c sec- 1. The omnidirectional geometric
factor for each detector is 3 x 10-2 cm2 while
the directional AB factor is 10-2 cm2 sr-
1. Hence, it is possible to obtain directional intensities of
high energy electrons with fluxes up to at least 109
cm-2 sec-1 sr-1, while singles rates
due to protons and electrons together can be used to measure
omnidirectional particle fluxes >1011 cm-2
sec-1. The capability of this detector configuration
exceeds the intensity values measured at the planned Voyager distance
of closest approach to Jupiter. For an exploratory mission to Saturn
and Uranus, however, such a capability is an absolute necessity.
Current Mode Operation
Although the LEMPA subsystem can handle particle intensities up to
1011 cm- 2 sec- 1 sr-1 in
a discrete particle counting mode (entirely adequate for the Jovian
encounter), there exists the possibility that higher fluxes of low
energy (<1 MeV) particles may be encountered in the Saturnian and
Uranian radiation environment. To prepare for such an eventuality a
current mode operation has been included for LEMPA sensors
and thereby extending the dynamic
range to fluxes ~1013 cm-2 sec-1
sr-1. In this mode the current due to the energy loss of
incoming particles from each detector is monitored over the range 5
nanoamperes to 5 microamperes.
B. LOW ENERGY CHARGED PARTICLE TELESCOPE (LEPT) SUBSYSTEM
The LEPT subsystem is an array of solid state detectors designed to measure the charge and energy distributions of low and medium energy nuclei in environments where the intensity is expected to be relatively low (e.g., outer regions of planetary magnetospheres and the interplanetary and (possibly) interstellar mediums). The detector arrangement is shown schematically in Figure 5, and consists of two multi- dE/dx x E systems placed back to back in order to use a common all solid-state active anticoincidence shield.
Particular emphasis has been placed on achieving the lowest energy of response attainable with solid state detector telescopes. The proposed configuration will measure the energy of, and separately identify protons and heavier nuclei from ~0.1 to 40 MeV/nucleon (two or three parameter measurements). One- parameter and multi-dE/dx measurements extend the energy range to ~0.05 and 500 MeV/nucleon. The specific functions of each detector element are given below.
Detector D1
The first detector of the LEPT dE/dx vs E system
consists of a set of two ~5 µ thick 50 mm2 and
one ~2 µ thick 25 mm2 surface barrier
detectors. Each detector is arranged at an appropriate angle to the
axis of the telescope so that variation of the
E signal over the angular field of view of the telescope
is minimized. The signals from each of the units are independently
amplified and fed to several window type discriminators (for counting
rate information), to a particle identifier system (for species rate
and priority data with detector D2), and for sampling by a 256 channel
pulse-height analyzer.
Detector D2
This large area (8 cm2), ~150 µ thick detector
serves as the total E detector for LEPT for particles
penetrating the D1 detectors. It is operated in anticoincidence with
detectors A1 to A8, and in coincidence with detector D1. Pulses from
this detector are log-amplified and fed into threshold discriminators
for rate data and into a 256 channel pulse-height analyzer. The D1 and
D2 signals are used in one of the particle identifier systems to
provide good species resolution in a counting mode which greatly
increases the dynamic range of the pulse-height analyzer scheme. For
example, the identifier system can accept up to ~105 events
per second while the PHA can only transmit 1 to 2 events per second.
The E vs
E signals in the D1, D2 combination are shown in Figure 6a for detectors in the first flight unit
of LECP. The error bars are FWHM values and represent the expected
energy resolution of the system as verified from prototype
calibrations. Solid lines in this figure denote the boundaries of
several particle identifier channels with telemetry duty cycles of
100%, as discussed above. Figure 6b shows data
from the calibration of the first flight unit at the Rutgers/Bell
Tandem Van-de-Graaff accelerator, and includes nuclei of
He3, He4, Li6, O16,
S32, and Fe56. The curves expected on the bais
of Figure 6b have been sketched in. A
histogram across the helium lines shows separation of the
He3 and He4 peaks by 7 channels, although the
density of points in Figure 6b makes this
isotope separation invisible.
Detectors A1 - A8
These detectors define an anticoincidence cylinder and have typical
dimensions of 2.3 cm x 6 cm x 1 mm. Such detectors are highly
preferable to scintillator-photomultiplier combinations for
anticoincidence logic. Each pair of detectors has a separate
preamplifier-amplifier chain and can be commanded off separately. By
connecting two pairs of detector outputs together, two separate
measurements of the omnidirectional penetrating particle rate are
obtained. Detectors A1-A4 are fed into a common discriminator as are
A5-A8; thus, the coincidence rate between the two (independent) halves
of the anticoincidence cup is relatively free of the background
induced by the onboard RTG power supply.
Detectors D3 and D4
These detectors are used in a dE/dx vs E
combination to extend the energy range of the telescope from ~4 to ~40
MeV/nucleon. Both detectors are 2450 µ thick, 8.5
cm2 lithium drifted detectors which serve as total E
sensors. The signals from both D3 and D4 are log-amplified and fed
into threshold discriminators and pulse-height analyzers, in the same
manner as in the case of the D1, D2 and D5 detectors. Both are in
anticoincidence with the 8 A detectors, to insure appropriate particle
angular response and energy definition as well as to minimize
background.
Detector D5
This detector is ~90 µ thick, 8 cm2 and is used
as a E detector in the medium energy
end of the LEPT. In combination with detectors D3 and D4, the output
of detector D5 is fed to the particle identifier system to provide
species rate data and priority information for the detailed pulse
height analyses. The expected E signals from
the D5, D4 combination are plotted in Figure
7. It is evident from the figure that good isotope resolution is
expected from hydrogen on up, including oxygen. Appropriate particle
identifier channels are also shown on this diagram.
Logarithmic Amplifiers and Particle Identifiers
The use of logarithmic amplifiers enables us to employ simple adder
circuits in order to calculate the relationship
EE
for particle energy loss in the silicon detectors. The
simple electronic computation of a particle's energy loss in each of a
series of detectors makes possible the use of an onboard particle
identifier, resulting in greatly improved rate data for major charge
groups. Further, the use of the particle identifier information
enhances the utility and effectiveness of the priority system. Most
importantly the logarithmic amplifiers give constant resolution
throughout the entire energy range of response of a detector (from
~0.1 to > 1000 MeV).
Priority Scheme
As noted above, it is not possible to transmit more than 1 or 2 pulse-
height analyzed events/second due to bit-rate limitations.
Incorporated in the system logic is a rotating three-level priority
scheme which is based upon particle Z (atomic number). Group I
contains channels responding to heavy nuclei and have the highest
priority in pulse height analysis; Group II contains channels of light
and medium nuclei (second priority), while Group III includes those
channels responding to protons and alpha particles (third priority).
To insure, however, that all groups are equally represented in
environments with relatively intense fluxes of all species, the
priority is rotated according to the event read out last. If the last
event belonged to Group I then, after readout, Group II has the
highest priority and Group III will be intermediate; if the event read
out last belonged in Group II, then Group III would have the highest
priority and I will be intermediate; finally, if the event read out
was in Group III, then Group I will have the highest priority and
Group II will be intermediate. In this manner, equal statistical
weight will be obtained for all particle species in relatively intense
environments. This is particularly important in the distant
magnetosphere of Jupiter where large fluxes of low energy ions are
expected to be present.
Geometric Factors
The geometric factor for D1D2D3 events is ~0.48 cm2
sr- 1, while that for D2D3D4 events is ~2.3 cm2
sr- 1 and that for D5D4A events is ~1.7 cm2
sr-1. For penetrating particles (D3D4A) the geometric
factor is ~4 cm2 sr-1. The characteristics of
the LEPT system are summarized in Table I. The
energy coverage for both the LEPT and LEMPA subsystems is shown in Figure 7.
Stepping Platform
The scientific importance of making anisotropy measurements for both
the cruise and encounter phases of the mission was emphasized in
Sections I and II. Because the Voyager spacecraft has a fixed
orientation, it is not possible to obtain angular distribution
measurements in the ecliptic plane by utilizing spacecraft spin. It is
therefore necessary to use either multiple detector heads or to rotate
the detector system at some appropriate rate. The latter method has
been chosen as the most reliable and efficient from the standpoint of
weight and power, and the method which will produce the most accurate
and complete dataset. A gear-drive motor steps both detector
subsystems through eight positions per revolution at the rate of one
revolution per 48 minutes during the cruise mode
(Figure 9). A fixed sunshield at 0° prevents
and D1 from viewing the Sun directly (an important
consideration during the early part of the mission). During the
planetary encounter mode the rate is increased to one of two
periods(192 sec or 48 sec), depending on availability of spacecraft
power. Normal scan sequence proceeds through sectors
(Figure 9)8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1-1-2-3-4-5-6-7-8-8-7.... Note that
continuous rotation in one direction is not possible because of the
feed-through cable. The stepping platform can be stopped at any
position for any length of time or perform an abbreviated scan view
via ground command. Two other important applications of the stepping
motor and sunshield are:(a) it is possible to unambiguously obtain
background measurements in all detectors in all particle environments;
this is particularly important in the Jovian environment where
foreground from background need to be separated; (b) the sunshield
contains small electron and alpha particle (Tc-99 and Am-241)
radioactive sources for inflight calibrations of both subsystems.
Command and Data System (CDS)
The CDS is a major electronic subsystem of the LECP instrument which
performs a large number of processing, storage, control, timing and
interface functions. These functions are described very briefly
below.
The CDS accepts 42 LEPT discriminators, 33 LEMPA discriminators, and 5 coincidence strobes and generates 88 rate channels according to a set of logic equations. Rate data are accumulated in sixty-two 24- bit scalers allowing 100% duty cycle for nearly all channels. The accumulators are read in groups of four 10-bit (log-compressed) words according to one of several programs in the spacecraft Flight Data System (FDS). The rate logic is also used in the priority system to select and identify LEPT events for Pulse Height Analysis. The CDS activates the PHA system and stores four 8-bit pulse heights and an 8- bit ID code. The 40-bit PHA 'events' are sampled by FDS command. The mode and state of the instrument are controlled by four 12-bit command words (2-bits ID, 10-bits control).The interface with the spacecraft for receipt of digital command words and for data output is fully redundant.
Modes of Operation
The measurements using the detector system described in the preceding
sections are to be performed in two environments, i.e., the
magnetospheres of Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus and the interplanetary
medium. The magnetospheres can be further subdivided into the distant
magnetosphere (bow shock, magnetopause, tail) and near magnetosphere
(trapped radiation belts). We thus utilize three modes of operation to
obtain optimum science coverage:
(1) Cruise Mode - During this mode both detector systems will collect data, with the exception of the AB, and ' subsystems of LEMPA, which are turned OFF. The stepping rate is 1 revolution in 48 minutes. This mode of operation is appropriate for the interplanetary medium where particle fluxes are not too large. The bit rate is allocated to 2/3 for the PHA data and 1/3 for the rate data.
(2) Far Encounter Mode-Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus - Sixty days prior to closest approach to the planet the stepping platform rate is increased to 1 revolution per minute. The experiment bit rate increases to 600 bps. At this time we allocate 1/3 of the bits to PHA data and 2/3 to rate data.
(3) Near Encounter Mode-Jupiter - At ~25 to 15RJ we will switch OFF (by command) all LEPT detectors and switch ON all remaining LEMPA detectors (i.e., AB, , ').
To insure that valuable continuity in the data between LEPT and LEMPA is maintained, provisions have been made to sample each of the two subsystems on a 50% duty cycle between the Far Encounter and Near Encounter modes. This will be particularly valuable in the encounters of Saturn and Uranus, where long communication times and a totally unknown environment could compromise the measurements in any one mode.
Inflight Calibration and Housekeeping
The instruments on the Voyager mission must have an operating lifetime
of at least four years, while an extended mission could increase the
lifetime to perhaps ~ten years. Inflight calibrations throughout this
period are therefore imperative. The calibration system for the LECP
provides the following checks on instrument performance: (1) A
continuous train of test pulses is fed into all preamplifier test
inputs in order to maintain a check of amplifier gains, discriminator
thresholds, and pulse-height analyzer linearity and performance (Peletier, 1975). (2) The test pulser
determines both the 12% and 88%discriminator trigger levels so that
the full-width at half-maximum noise characteristics of each pulse
channel can be measured. (3) Radioactive sources mounted on the light
shield provide a complete systems calibration for LEPT and LEMPA
, ,
and detector systems. Thus, amplifier
gains, discriminator settings and noise readings will be read on the
analog telemetry subcom; PHA linearity data will be contained in the
digital data. Upon completion of the calibration sequence the LECP
pulse generator will be commanded OFF.
The description of the LECP instrument in this paper has emphasized the physical description of the detectors and their applicability to various environments. A detailed description of most of the electronic subsystems is given in the paper by Peletier et al. (1977).
4. Summary
The experiment described here satisfies all major scientific and measurement objectives in the area of low energy charged particle investigations for both environments of interest, i.e., planetary magnetospheres and the interplanetary medium. The extremely large dynamic range (~10-5 to >1012 cm-2 sec- 1 sr-1) combined with wide coverage in energy and species assures that sufficient information will be available to characterize almost any energetic particle environment encountered by the Voyager spacecraft in a comprehensive manner. 'Second generation' studies of the Jovian magnetosphere are assured at energies, intensities, and species not available with Pioneer 10 and 11 investigations. Some of the measurements will be performed for the first time in any planetary magnetosphere (including Earth's), e.g., detailed measurements of the charge composition of trapped radiation and the full particle distribution function in three dimensions. The time resolution of the measurements (as small as ~60 millisec) rival those obtained in any of several Earth-orbiting spacecraft. Finally, the multiplicity of detectors coupled with built-in redundancy of key subsystems (e.g., redundant PHA's, data output lines, etc.) assures a high degree of reliability for the whole experiment.
Acknowledgements
We wish to express our most sincere appreciation to Messrs D. P. Peletier, S. A. Gary, R. G. King, J. W. Kohl, D. E. Fort, J. T. Mueller, J. H. Crawford, R. E. Thompson, Dr. E. P. Keath and many others at JHU/APL for their tremendous enthusiasm and the many long hours that went into making the LECP experiment a success. Thanks are also due to J. Cain, E. Tums and many others at the University of Maryland, and C. G. Maclennan of Bell Laboratories for their contributions to this program. In addition, we wish to thank the JPL cognizant engineer D. E. Griffith, cognizant scientist E. Franzgrote, Messrs. G. L. Reisdorf, W. G. Fawcett, H. M. Schurmeier, J. R. Casani, J. E. Long and Dr. E. C. Stone of Cal Tech for their assistance and cooperation during the course of this work. We thank personnel at the Rutgers/Bell Tandem Van-de-Graaff accelerator (supported in part by NSF) for their generous help during calibrations. We also express our appreciation to Mr. S. K. Brown at GSFC for his dedicated help in performing LEMPA calibrations. The LECP experiment was supported by the Office of Lunar and Planetary Programs at NASA Headquarters under Task I of Contract N00017-72-C-4401 between The Johns Hopkins University and the Department of the Navy. We thank Dr. M. A. Mitz and Messrs A. Reetz, Jr., J. W. Keller and R. A. Mills of NASA Headquarters for their support during various phases of this program.
TABLE I
Summary of detector characteristics-LECP
Fig. 1 (a) Integral flux
in peak LEMPA sector (direction of plasma flow divided by plasma density
J0/N) for energy
thresholds Ep
15 keV (for three flow velocities) and
Ee10 keV (negligible dependence on flow velocity) as
a function of plasma temperature (Eth = kT).
(b) Angular flux distribution (integral above
Ep
= 15 keV plasma flowing at 100 km s-
1). (Courtesy of Drs. E. C. Roelof and R. E.
Gold.)
Fig. 2. A picture of the
first flight unit of the LECP experiment. The low energy aperture of both
LEMPA and LEPT are shown; the high energy apertures are facing in the
opposite direction (180°). Inflight radioactive calibration sources are
mounted on the sun shield for both LEMPA and the LEPT. The entire
assembly (including two electronics boxes) above the stepping platform
is rotated into eight angular sectors.
Fig. 3. Schematic drawing
of the LEMPA and dome detector assembly. Incoming electrons are swept away
from detector by the magnet and counted in
detectors and
. Detectors ,
' are insensitive to electrons of any energy. Tungsten
shielding eliminates interference from high energy penetrating
electrons in most parts of the Jovian magnetosphere. Thicknesses for
detectors are nominal.
Fig 4. (a) Experimental
response of detector in LEMPA to protons; LT and HT
denote 'low threshold' and 'high threshold', respectively in channel
P1. Dashed lines indicate expected thresholds at
high energies.
(b) Angular response of
detector in LEMPA to a undirectional beam of incident electrons;
note that 10 keV electrons are readily counted by the detector.
(c) Data from the same
calibration as in (b)
, but showing the differential energy channels at maximum
electron response. Preliminary data for detectors
and are also shown.
Fig. 5. Schematic diagram
of the LEPT assembly. Detector thicknesses and areas may differ somewhat
between the first and second flight units.
Fig. 6. (a)
E vs E plot for the
D1a, D2 detectors on flight unit No. 1. Actual detector thicknesses
and system noise levels have been used. Thick solid lines show the
boundaries of rate channels defined by onboard logic and particle
identifier circuitry. Circled numbers indicate the channel number,
while energy levels indicated along both axis give the discriminator
thresholds for each detector
(b) Calibrations at the Rutgers/Bell Tandem Van-de-Graaff accelerator
with He3,
He4,
Li6,
O16,
S32 and
Fe56
Fig 7. Same as
Figure 6a but for
the D5, D4 detectors in flight unit No 1. Calibrations have verified the
expected response.
Fig. 8. Energy and species
coverage diagram for the LECP experiment. Numbers in LEPT blocks indicate
channel number in the instrument data system. The figure is drawn for
flight unit No. 1. Energy coverage for flight unit No. 2 may differ
somewhat from that shown above.
Fig. 9. Sectoring scheme
for the LECP experiment detector assemblies. The sequence is
8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1-1-2-3-4-5-6-7-8-8-7-.... Radioactive calibration sources for
both LEPT and LEMPA are mounted inside the sun shield.